The tenth anniversary of the S&P 500 Index bull market is coming up on March 9. As the U.S. stock rally’s double-digit birthday nears, we’ve reflected a lot on the durability of the current economic cycle. The U.S. economic expansion is entering its 118th month, on track to become the longest recovery on record in July.
Some things in life get better with age, but recession calls have grown louder recently amid heightened global uncertainty and market volatility. While it is important to be mindful of where we are in the cycle, we see a lot of evidence that this economic cycle has enough fuel left in its tank to persevere at least through the end of this year and could prove durable.
SLOW, BUT STEADY
In past economic cycles, slow but steady growth has won the race. Since 1970, cycles with annual gross domestic product (GDP) growth higher than 4% lasted about five years on average, while cycles with annual growth lower than 4% lasted about nine years on average [Figure 1]. While slow growth in this cycle has been frustrating at times, especially after a swift and painful downturn, it has helped extend the life of this cycle and keep excesses in check. Inflation-adjusted GDP has expanded an average of 2.3% annually in this cycle, the slowest pace of growth among all expansions in recent memory, and a key contributor to the expansion’s near-record age.
Steady economic growth has been helped in part by extraordinarily supportive monetary policy for much of the cycle and a cautious, gradual approach to tightening. The Federal Reserve’s (Fed) supportive policy efforts have been in place for many years, but policymakers only started increasing rates in December 2015, more than six years into the expansion. Since then, the Fed has implemented nine 25-basis point (.25%) hikes, matching the slowest Fed hiking pace in tightening cycles since 1970. This tightening cycle is one of the longest on record, yet inflation-adjusted interest rates are barely above zero. Inflation (measured by core personal consumption expenditures) has been climbing since 2015, but it’s still only hovering around the Fed’s 2% target, and wage growth, while healthy, remains manageable. Muted inflation can be attributed to several structural factors like demographics and globalization, but the Fed has played a pivotal role in promoting stable pricing while restricting growth only minimally. We believe this pragmatic and gradual approach will continue to be effective, and we see minimal chances of a policy mistake en route to a soft landing from the current modest slowdown.
The lingering effects of fiscal stimulus may also provide an extra boost to the expansion, especially if companies ramp up capital expenditures once we see a United States-China trade resolution. Supply-side fiscal stimulus can have a positive impact on output for several years as consumers and businesses reap the benefits of tax cuts and fiscal incentives.
While we’ve noted recently that coincident economic reports have sent mixed messages about economic conditions, leading economic data hint to more runway in the expansion. The Conference Board’s Leading Economic Index (LEI), composed of 10 leading economic indicators, rose 3.5% year over year in January, its 110th straight gain. Leading indicators typically show pronounced weakness as the economy approaches recession, and year-over-year growth in the gauge has turned negative an average of seven months before each recession going back to 1970 [Figure 2]. The current rate of change remains well off that mark.